RealtyLens
for saleRealtyLens property overview
$1,299,900

159 Aspinwall St

Staten Island, NY, 10307
View more Staten Island, NY property pages
6Beds
7Baths
4,188Sqft
$310$/sqft

Listing Notes

Welcome to 159 Aspinwall Street, a spacious 4,188 sq. ft. legal two-family Center Hall Colonial situated on an oversized 9,869 sq. ft. lot in one of Staten Island's most desirable South Shore locations. This home offers an ideal blend of size, layout, and potential, featuring four bedrooms and four bathrooms in the main residence along with a large two-bedroom apartment on the second floor, perfect for extended family or rental income. The main level includes a gracious entry, formal living room, formal dining room, and a large family room with a cozy fireplace. The finished basement provides additional living space and includes a second fireplace, offering great versatility for recreation or extended living. Additional features include hardwood floors throughout, a multi-zone heating system, a two-car garage, and excellent curb appeal. The property boasts a large yard with a built-in in-ground pool, making it perfect for outdoor enjoyment. While the interior is solid with great bones, it is dated and priced accordingly, offering a rare opportunity to customize a substantial home to your taste. Conveniently located near schools, parks, shopping centers, restaurants, and public transportation, this property delivers tremendous value and potential.

Market Insights

Below nearby median-32%

$310/sqft vs a nearby median of $456/sqft.

Nearby median$456/sqft
Nearby properties12
Property size4,188 sqft
  • -32% versus the nearby median price per square foot.
  • Price history is limited, so current comps matter more than trend alone.
  • 4,188 sqft creates a usable price-per-square-foot read.

Pricing Read

Yardstick fair value$1.75M$1.59M$1.91M · 50% confidence
vs ask $1.30M−$448k (−34.5%)

Asking price is about 34.5% below the fair value — likely to draw competing offers if it's still on market.

$456/sqft median across 11 tight comps × 4,188 sqft= $1.91M
  • Days-on-market gravity−$57k −3.0%
  • Transit access−$29k −1.5%
  • Mid-century building era−$29k −1.5%
  • Sparse street life−$29k −1.5%
  • Visible condition issues−$19k −1.0%
Cumulative NYC adjustments−$162k−8.5%

Property Read

FreshnessCurrent market data

The listing facts are current enough for an initial property review.

Market Position-32% vs nearby

The asking price per square foot is below the nearby median, which can be worth a closer comp check.

Price MovementInitial price point

Price history is still limited; review again as more market activity becomes available.

Diligence Read3 items to check
AI ReadinessReady to analyze
Assistant read

Generate a buyer-agent read of this listing — pricing, risks, comp check, and negotiation leverage. Takes a few seconds.

Generated from the facts shown on this page and nearby market data. Not a professional appraisal.

Listing Details

Days on market
176 days
Last price change
No change recorded
Listed
Nov 17, 2025
Photos
51 photos
Property type
multi family
Status
for sale
Last sold
Mar 5, 1992 · $300,000
Garage
2 spaces

Features & Amenities

CarportSwimming PoolTwo Or More StoriesGarage 1 Or MoreGarage 2 Or MoreBasementBig YardRental PropertyFireplaceHardwood FloorsDenSpacious Family RoomFamily RoomParkShopping

Photos

Building Facts

Year built
1980
Stories
2
Total units
2
Residential units
2
Building area
3,104 sqft
Lot size
10,019 sqft
Land use
One and two family buildings
Building class
B2

From NYC public records where available.

Price History

May 4, 2026Initial record
$1,299,900for sale

You can also find this listing on StreetEasy.

Listing data sourced from streeteasy.com. RealtyLens enriches and contextualises it for you, but the original listing lives on the source.