RealtyLens
for saleRealtyLens property overview
$3,400,000

164 Underhill Ave

Brooklyn, NY, 11238
View more Brooklyn, NY property pages
4Beds
7Baths
940Sqft
$3617$/sqft

Listing Notes

Perfect 1031 Tax Exchange Property! Welcome to 164 Underhill Avenue, a remarkable property nestled in the heart of Brooklyn's coveted Prospect Heights neighborhood. This fully renovated five-family residence blends modern luxury with classic charm, making it an outstanding investment opportunity or a spacious home for an owner-occupant. Spanning 4, 441 square feet, the property offers four bedrooms and seven bathrooms, providing both space and privacy. The owner's duplex stands out with two bedrooms, two-and-a-half bathrooms, and a private garden perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The kitchen features stainless steel appliances, two-toned custom cabinetry, and elegant marble countertops, creating a sophisticated yet functional space. Carrara marble bathrooms add a refined touch throughout. Split system heating and cooling provides year round comfort. The second and third floors include a renovated studio and a one-bedroom apartment, both offering strong rental income and consistent demand. All units are set up separately with mechanicals for heating, cooling and hot water. Set on a picturesque, tree-lined block, the property provides a quiet urban retreat while being close to the Brooklyn Botanic Garden and Prospect Park. Enjoy easy access to neighborhood favorites like Radio Bakery, Leland Eating and Drinking House, and Union Market, with the Grand Army Plaza Farmers Market just a short walk away. Conveniently connect to the 2, 3, 4, 5, B, D, N, Q, and R trains at Atlantic Terminal, and it's also within walking distance of Barclays Center.

Market Insights

Above nearby median+201%

$3617/sqft vs a nearby median of $1203/sqft.

Nearby median$1203/sqft
Nearby properties8
Property size940 sqft
  • +201% versus the nearby median price per square foot.
  • Price history is limited, so current comps matter more than trend alone.
  • 940 sqft creates a usable price-per-square-foot read.

Pricing Read

Yardstick fair value$1.09M$993k$1.19M · 50% confidence
vs ask $3.40M+$2.31M (+67.9%)

Asking price is about 67.9% above where comps + adjustments land — there is room to negotiate.

$1,203/sqft median across 7 tight comps × 940 sqft= $1.13M
  • Open Class C HPD violations−$68k −6.0%
  • Transit access+$28k +2.5%
  • Pre-war character+$28k +2.5%
  • Visible condition issues−$17k −1.5%
  • Virtually staged−$11k −1.0%
Cumulative NYC adjustments−$40k−3.5%

Property Read

FreshnessVerification recommended

The page is useful for research, but the status and price should be verified before acting.

Market Position+201% vs nearby

The property is priced above the nearby median per square foot, so condition, building quality, and exact location need to justify the higher ask.

Price MovementInitial price point

Price history is still limited; review again as more market activity becomes available.

Diligence Read2 items to check
AI ReadinessReady to analyze
Assistant read

Generate a buyer-agent read of this listing — pricing, risks, comp check, and negotiation leverage. Takes a few seconds.

Generated from the facts shown on this page and nearby market data. Not a professional appraisal.

Listing Details

Days on market
8 days
Last price change
No change recorded
Listed
May 4, 2026
Photos
20 photos
Property type
multi family
Status
for sale
Last sold
Apr 14, 2015 · $1,505,000

Features & Amenities

Central AirRental PropertyInvestment OpportunityDen

Photos

Building Facts

Year built
1900
Stories
2
Total units
4
Residential units
4
Building area
2,244 sqft
Lot size
2,000 sqft
Land use
Multi-family walk-up buildings
Building class
C3

From NYC public records where available.

Price History

May 4, 2026Initial record
$3,400,000for sale

Public Records

DOB violations1 open

3 total recorded against the building

HPD violations8 open

6 class C (immediately hazardous)

ACRIS documents50

Tax-lot deed, mortgage, and transfer records on file

311 calls (12 mo)34,223

Top: illegal parking

Top complaint types in ZIP 11238

  • Illegal Parking6,166
  • HEAT/HOT WATER3,070
  • Noise - Residential2,033
  • Noise - Helicopter1,915
  • Noise - Street/Sidewalk1,377

Recent DOB

  • Jul 6, 2018V-DOB VIOLATION - ACTIVE · C-CONSTRUCTION OTHER OPTIONAL
  • Apr 5, 2016V*-DOB VIOLATION - DISMISSED · LANDMK-LANDMARK NONE
  • Apr 5, 2016V*-DOB VIOLATION - DISMISSED · LANDMK-LANDMARK NONE

Recent HPD

  • Mar 25, 2026Class C · § 27-2005, 27-2007, 27-2041.1 HMC, §238, § 309; § 107 (2) ( C) MDL AND 28 RCNY §25-171: REPLACE OR REPAIR THE SELF-CLOSING DOORS THAT IS MISSING OR DEFECTIVE HINGES AT DOOR IN T...
  • Mar 25, 2026Class C · § 27-2029 ADM CODE PROVIDE AN ADEQUATE SUPPLY OF HEAT FOR THE APARTMENT IN THE ENTIRE APARTMENT LOCATED AT APT 2R, 2nd STORY, 1st APARTMENT FROM SOUTH AT WEST
  • Mar 25, 2026Class C · § 27-2005 HMC: PROPERLY REPAIR OR REPLACE THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE HVAC UNIT AT EAST WALL IN THE 1st ROOM FROM EAST LOCATED AT APT 2R, 2nd STORY, 1st APARTMENT FROM SOUTH AT WEST
  • Mar 25, 2026Class C · § 27-2031 ADM CODE PROVIDE HOT WATER AT ALL HOT WATER FIXTURES IN THE ENTIRE APARTMENT LOCATED AT APT 2R, 2nd STORY, 1st APARTMENT FROM SOUTH AT WEST

Sourced from NYC Open Data (DOB, HPD, ACRIS). Updated as the city republishes — check the original source for live status.

You can also find this listing on StreetEasy.

Listing data sourced from streeteasy.com. RealtyLens enriches and contextualises it for you, but the original listing lives on the source.