RealtyLens
for saleRealtyLens property overview
$1,599,999

21 Sprague Ave

Staten Island, NY, 10307
View more Staten Island, NY property pages
5Beds
4Baths
N/ASqft
N/A$/sqft

Listing Notes

One-of-a-kind custom 2-family resort-style colonial in the prestigious Tottenville neighborhood. 6 bedrooms and 4 baths across 5,000 sqft of living space on a massive lot. This exceptional property provides a blend of luxury, classic design, and modern amenities. The entire first floor is adorned with radiant heating, custom wainscotting, and moldings, high hat lighting, porcelain tiles, and a sunken living room with vaulted ceilings. The formal dining room adds to the elegance of the space. The first floor also features the master bedroom with a walk-in closet, 3/4 bath, and its own split unit AC, as well as 1 bedroom/office facing the front. The kitchen is a chef's dream with an eat-in design, quartz on the countertops backsplash, and island. Wolf range with pot filler, double-wide Subzero fridge and wine fridge combo, walk-in pantry/laundry room, and soft-close cabinets make this a culinary haven. The first floor also features a 3/4 bath, 8 solar panels leased for just $80/month, 3 AC units, and a tankless water system. A separate studio/loft apartment with a 3/4 bath, kitchen connections, and a hidden closet provides the perfect space for guests or a home office. The second floor boasts 4 bedrooms, 2 baths, a steam shower, and a massive walk-in closet with custom shelving, providing a luxurious spa-like experience. The exterior of the home is equally impressive, featuring a children's playground, a 6ft pool with a slide, resort-style gazebos, and an HDMI connection for backyard TV viewing. The cobblestone driveway with pathway lighting leads to the large 2-car garage that includes its own split unit and durable epoxy floors. This custom 2 family resort-style colonial in Tottenville offers a unique opportunity to own a luxurious and comfortable home in a sought-after neighborhood. Don't miss your chance to experience the incredible features and charm this property has to offer. Contact us directly for a private tour or visit one of our frequent open houses.

Market Insights

Market comparison pendingN/A

Comparable price-per-square-foot data is still developing for this home.

Nearby median$408/sqft
Nearby properties12
Property sizeN/A
  • 12 nearby properties available for comparison.
  • Price history is limited, so current comps matter more than trend alone.
  • Square footage is missing, so valuation should lean more heavily on comps and condition.

Estimated Monthly Payment

Per month, all-in$10,516/mo

Assumes 20% down, 7.00% APR over 30 years. Tax and insurance are national-average estimates — your lender quote will differ.

  • Principal & interest$8,516
  • Property tax (est.)$1,467
  • Home insurance (est.)$533

Property Read

FreshnessVerification recommended

The page is useful for research, but the status and price should be verified before acting.

Market Position12 nearby signals

Nearby inventory exists, but square-footage or price data is incomplete for a clean median comparison.

Price MovementInitial price point

Price history is still limited; review again as more market activity becomes available.

Diligence Read1 item to check
AI ReadinessNeeds verification
Assistant read

Generate a buyer-agent read of this listing — pricing, risks, comp check, and negotiation leverage. Takes a few seconds.

Generated from the facts shown on this page and nearby market data. Not a professional appraisal.

Listing Details

Days on market
398 days
Last price change
No change recorded
Listed
Apr 9, 2025
Photos
38 photos
Property type
multi family
Status
for sale
Last sold
Feb 2, 2022 · $1,670,000
Garage
1 space

Features & Amenities

CarportCentral AirHardwood FloorsSwimming PoolGarage 1 Or MoreVaulted CeilingMaster BedroomSolar SystemOpen HouseSolar PanelsPlayground

Photos

Building Facts

Year built
1940
Stories
2
Total units
2
Residential units
2
Building area
4,512 sqft
Lot size
9,576 sqft
Land use
One and two family buildings
Building class
B2

From NYC public records where available.

Price History

May 4, 2026Initial record
$1,599,999for sale

Public Records

DOB violations0 open

2 total recorded against the building

HPD violations0 open

0 total recorded

ACRIS documents2

Tax-lot deed, mortgage, and transfer records on file

311 calls (12 mo)4,520

Top: illegal parking

Top complaint types in ZIP 10307

  • Illegal Parking488
  • Noise - Residential466
  • Noise - Commercial320
  • Snow or Ice264
  • Water System209

Recent DOB

  • Nov 22, 2018V*-DOB VIOLATION - DISMISSED · C-CONSTRUCTION OTHER OPTIONAL
  • Nov 22, 2018V*-DOB VIOLATION - DISMISSED · C-CONSTRUCTION OTHER OPTIONAL

Sourced from NYC Open Data (DOB, HPD, ACRIS). Updated as the city republishes — check the original source for live status.

You can also find this listing on StreetEasy.

Listing data sourced from streeteasy.com. RealtyLens enriches and contextualises it for you, but the original listing lives on the source.