The listing facts are current enough for an initial property review.
5396 Arthur Kill Rd
Listing Notes
Meticulous 4 bedroom, 3 bath detached home in Tottenville. The first floor of this newly renovated home features custom kitchen with new appliances, living room, dining room, enclosed side porch, laundry room, front porch, 1/2 bath, and door to large yard. The second floor features 3 spacious bedrooms and custom full bath. The third level features the 4th bedroom with custom bath. The basement is large and unfinished with plenty of potential. This house sits on a 5303 square ft corner lot and features a large detached 2 car garage. Enormous potential and possibilities for an ADU, workshop, business, or conversion to a multifamily home. Home also has updated heating, AC and electrical system to 200 amps. This home is located near all major transportation and shopping. This home is perfect for so many types of buyers- large families, business owners, investors and more...
Market Insights
$409/sqft vs a nearby median of $451/sqft.
- -9.3% versus the nearby median price per square foot.
- Price history is limited, so current comps matter more than trend alone.
- 2,200 sqft creates a usable price-per-square-foot read.
Pricing Read
Asking price is about 9.7% below the fair value — likely to draw competing offers if it's still on market.
- Transit access+$25k +2.5%
- Mid-century building era−$15k −1.5%
- Sparse street life−$15k −1.5%
Property Read
The asking price per square foot is below the nearby median, which can be worth a closer comp check.
Price history is still limited; review again as more market activity becomes available.
Generate a buyer-agent read of this listing — pricing, risks, comp check, and negotiation leverage. Takes a few seconds.
Generated from the facts shown on this page and nearby market data. Not a professional appraisal.
Listing Details
- Days on market
- 28 days
- Last price change
- No change recorded
- Listed
- Apr 14, 2026
- Photos
- 39 photos
- Property type
- single family
- Status
- for sale
- Last sold
- Feb 14, 2025 · $500,000
- Garage
- 2 spaces
Features & Amenities
Photos
Building Facts
- Year built
- 1965
- Stories
- 3
- Total units
- 1
- Residential units
- 1
- Building area
- 1,620 sqft
- Lot size
- 5,227 sqft
- Land use
- One and two family buildings
- Building class
- A1
From NYC public records where available.
Price History
Public Records
0 total recorded against the building
0 total recorded
Tax-lot deed, mortgage, and transfer records on file
Top: illegal parking
Top complaint types in ZIP 10307
- Illegal Parking488
- Noise - Residential466
- Noise - Commercial320
- Snow or Ice264
- Water System209
Sourced from NYC Open Data (DOB, HPD, ACRIS). Updated as the city republishes — check the original source for live status.