RealtyLens
for saleRealtyLens property overview
$5,650,000

257 W 86th St # 1 & 2A

New York, NY, 10024
View more New York, NY property pages
3Beds
3Baths
2,800Sqft
$2018$/sqft

Listing Notes

Architectural Granduer; From Legendary Ballet Studio to an Architects Upper West Side Family Home A Unique Offering of a Gut-Renovated, Pin Drop Quiet, Three Bedroom Designer Duplex. Experience peaceful, refined living in this impeccably designed and meticulously renovated three bedroom, three bath home at 257 West 86th Street. Approximately 2, 800sf, this re-imagined duplex transcends the definition of turn-key, fusing the highest level of architectural skill, sophisticated taste, the highest standards of craftsmanship, dramatic scale, and pre-war details that are original to the building, and maintained with integrity. The Residence: Apartment 1/2A was the former live/work Dance Studio belonging to ballet legend, Raoul Gelabert. The apartment was brought down to its shell and rebuilt by the architect and owner, with intention, detail, and love, spanning a multiple year project. The well-lit, double-height, 20-foot ceiling Great Room creates an immediate sense of drama and scale as you enter the apartment. The large, custom eat-in kitchen is a showpiece, featuring custom cabinetry, a generous peninsula table, premium integrated appliances by Wolff, Dacor, and Cove, and finally lots of counter top surface area designed to provide workspace for the culinary enthusiast, the frequent host, or for everyday living. The custom cabinetry is in high gloss lacquer, with metal frames that surround the doors and drawers throughout the kitchen; practical to protect these highly used components, avoiding chipping of the edges. Beyond the great room, an office gallery with custom cabinetry and a decorative fireplace does double duty as both a work space for two and a recreation space for many. Off of the office, a dedicated media/den has the versatility to also be a guest room (fourth bedroom) with a built-in murphy bed. The first floor is complete with three closets, one of which is a large walk-in closet, and a luxurious full bath with tiles from Ann Sacks, cabinetry cabinets, and heated floors. The flexible floor plan currently offers three bedrooms and two full baths on the second floor, all bedrooms basking in Southern light. And finally, the entry foyer is an experience in itself with custom natural oak cabinetry, the stair wall design by Fresco Decorative Arts, the upholstered bench and polygons in Ultrasuede from Kravit and the sculptural glass staircase by Prime Glass. Two unique and cleverly hidden closets pull out from under the stairs for coat, hat, and shoe storage. The practical luxury of this home prioritizes utility and functionality without sacrificing style, boasting an in-unit washer/dryer closet with shelving, and an abundance of closets and built-in storage, where each closet is outfitted with lighting, shelving and drawers for maximum utility and easy access and visibility. The residence has central A/C with multiple zones to accommodate everyone's temperature preference. Baths are equipped with hidden storage drawers that are outfitted with designated electrical outlets so your bathroom countertops can remain appliance free. All the windows have been replaced from the original. The Building & Lifestyle: Situated in a premier FULL-SERVICE cooperative, residents enjoy a 24-hour doorman, a fitness center, and a landscaped roof deck. A well run co-op whose Local Law 11 was just completed. Positioned between Riverside and Central Parks, the location offers immediate access to the neighborhoods most celebrated dining, cultural landmarks, and the many options for transportation. Pet-friendly and perfectly executed, this duplex represents a rare opportunity to secure a truly standout residence in the heart of the Upper West Side. Apartment Features: Approx 2, 800SF High Ceilings Central A/C Washer/Dryer in unit Building Features: Full time Doorman Gym Laundry Pet Friendly

Market Insights

Above nearby median+16%

$2018/sqft vs a nearby median of $1736/sqft.

Nearby median$1736/sqft
Nearby properties12
Property size2,800 sqft
  • +16% versus the nearby median price per square foot.
  • Price history is limited, so current comps matter more than trend alone.
  • 2,800 sqft creates a usable price-per-square-foot read.

Pricing Read

Yardstick fair value$5.22M$4.75M$5.69M · 50% confidence
vs ask $5.65M+$431k (+7.6%)

Asking price is about 7.6% above where comps + adjustments land — there is room to negotiate.

$1,734/sqft median across 8 tight comps × 2,800 sqft= $4.86M
  • Transit access+$194k +4.0%
  • Pre-war character+$121k +2.5%
  • High-density walkability+$97k +2.0%
  • Visible condition issues−$49k −1.0%
Cumulative NYC adjustments+$364k+7.5%

Property Read

FreshnessCurrent market data

The listing facts are current enough for an initial property review.

Market Position+16% vs nearby

The property is priced above the nearby median per square foot, so condition, building quality, and exact location need to justify the higher ask.

Price MovementInitial price point

Price history is still limited; review again as more market activity becomes available.

Diligence Read3 items to check
AI ReadinessReady to analyze
Assistant read

Generate a buyer-agent read of this listing — pricing, risks, comp check, and negotiation leverage. Takes a few seconds.

Generated from the facts shown on this page and nearby market data. Not a professional appraisal.

Listing Details

Days on market
34 days
Last price change
No change recorded
Listed
Apr 8, 2026
Photos
25 photos
Property type
coop
Status
for sale

Features & Amenities

Central AirCity ViewDoormanElevatorGymDishwasherFireplaceHardwood FloorsRecreation FacilitiesViewTwo Or More StoriesHigh CeilingFloor PlanWalk In ClosetOfficeDenGreat RoomPark

Photos

Building Facts

Year built
1909
Stories
7
Total units
32
Residential units
32
Building area
1.54 ac
Lot size
7,550 sqft
Land use
Multi-family elevator buildings
Building class
D4

From NYC public records where available.

Price History

May 4, 2026Initial record
$5,650,000for sale

Public Records

DOB violations1 open

25 total recorded against the building

HPD violations6 open

6 total recorded

ACRIS documents94

Tax-lot deed, mortgage, and transfer records on file

311 calls (12 mo)16,343

Top: illegal parking

Top complaint types in ZIP 10024

  • Illegal Parking2,239
  • HEAT/HOT WATER2,038
  • Noise - Residential1,009
  • Noise750
  • Noise - Street/Sidewalk581

Recent DOB

  • May 31, 2018V*-DOB VIOLATION - DISMISSED · FISPNRF-NO REPORT AND / OR LATE FILING (FACADE) FACADE REQUIRED
  • Jun 10, 2014V*-DOB VIOLATION - Resolved · E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIRED
  • Jun 10, 2014V*-DOB VIOLATION - Resolved · E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIRED
  • Apr 25, 2013V*-DOB VIOLATION - Resolved · E-ELEVATOR ELEVATORREQUIRED

Recent HPD

  • Jun 22, 2001Class A · SECTION 27-2013 ADM CODE PAINT WITH LIGHT COLORED PAINT TO THE SATISFACTION OF THIS DEPARTMENT WALLS, CEILING IN THE BATHROOM LOCATED AT APT 3D, 3rd STORY, 2nd APARTMENT FROM WE...
  • Apr 5, 2001Class B · SECTION 27-2005 ADM CODE & 309 M/D LAW ABATE THE NUISANCE CONSISTING OF CONCEALED WATER LEAK AT THE CEILING IN THE BATHROOM LOCATED AT APT 3D, 5th STORY, 1st APARTMENT FROM WEST...
  • Apr 5, 2001Class B · SECTION 27-2005 ADM CODE REPAIR THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE PLASTERED SURFACES AND PAINT IN A UNIFORM COLOR THE CEILING AND WALLS IN THE BATHROOM LOCATED AT APT 3D, 5th STORY, 1st A...
  • Nov 29, 2000Class A · SECTION 27-2005 ADM CODE REPAIR THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE PLASTERED SURFACES AND PAINT IN A UNIFORM COLOR CEILING IN THE BATHROOM LOCATED AT APT 3D, 3rd STORY, APARTMENT AT NORTH

Sourced from NYC Open Data (DOB, HPD, ACRIS). Updated as the city republishes — check the original source for live status.

You can also find this listing on StreetEasy.

Listing data sourced from streeteasy.com. RealtyLens enriches and contextualises it for you, but the original listing lives on the source.